11408-01-B vs 11520-22 — Compare
Seymour Duncan Duff McKagan P-J Bass Pickup Set vs Seymour Duncan Active Mag Pickup
The Duff McKagan P-J is a high-output signature set for electric bass in hard rock and alternative styles, while the Active Mag is a budget acoustic instrument pickup for transparent amplification. These serve completely different instruments and genres—choose based on whether you're upgrading an electric bass or amplifying an acoustic guitar or similar instrument.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
Seymour Duncan Duff McKagan P-J Bass Pickup Set
Specs side by side
| Seymour Duncan Duff McKagan P-J Bass Pickup Set | Seymour Duncan Active Mag Pickup | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $218.00 | $209.00 |
| Brand | Seymour Duncan | Seymour Duncan |
| Series | Seymour Duncan Bass Pickups | — |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose Seymour Duncan Duff McKagan P-J Bass Pickup Set
- ✓ Signature design endorsed by Duff McKagan optimized for hard rock and heavy styles
- ✓ High-output Quarter Pound Precision neck pickup with large alnico 5 magnets for thick, defined low-end
- ✓ P-J configuration balances low-end punch with bright treble articulation
- ✓ Hand-built in Santa Barbara to professional standards; fits standard PJ routing without modification
Why choose Seymour Duncan Active Mag Pickup
- ✓ Budget-friendly price tier with professional-grade specs (89dBV noise floor, 0.0075% THD)
- ✓ Compact soundhole mount fits 3.75" to 4.2" acoustic instruments with minimal modification
- ✓ On-body volume and tone controls for easy shaping without external gear
- ✓ 160 hours of battery life per CR2032 set; transparent, hum-canceling design ideal for studio and live acoustic use
Frequently asked questions
What instruments do these work with?
The Duff McKagan P-J is designed for electric basses with P-J routing (Precision and Jazz pickup cavities). The Active Mag mounts in acoustic guitar or similar acoustic instrument soundholes measuring 3.75" to 4.2" in diameter.
Which is better for genre versatility?
The Duff McKagan P-J targets hard rock and alternative styles where its aggressive output and scooped-yet-punchy voice excel. The Active Mag suits folk, acoustic, and studio applications where transparency and minimal noise are priorities; the product notes it is not ideal for high-distortion genres.
Do either require soldering or modifications?
The Duff McKagan P-J fits standard PJ bass routing without modifications and requires soldering to install in a bass. The Active Mag mounts directly into compatible soundholes with minimal modification and runs on internal batteries.
What about noise performance?
The Active Mag features hum-canceling design with an 89dBV noise floor and 0.0075% THD, optimized for clean acoustic amplification. The Duff McKagan P-J prioritizes aggressive output and punchy tone for rock contexts rather than low-noise performance.