11108-16-NC vs 11108-31-B — Compare
Seymour Duncan Phat Cat Nickel Pickup Set vs Seymour Duncan Invader Black Pickup Set
The Phat Cat Nickel is a vintage-voiced P-90 retrofit for blues, jazz, and classic rock players seeking warm, articulate tone without guitar routing; the Invader Black is a high-output ceramic humbucker built for metal, hard rock, and heavy gain applications demanding punchy mids and thick lows. Choose based on genre and desired output level.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
Specs side by side
| Seymour Duncan Phat Cat Nickel Pickup Set | Seymour Duncan Invader Black Pickup Set | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $229.00 | $229.00 |
| Brand | Seymour Duncan | Seymour Duncan |
| Series | — | Seymour Duncan Invader |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose Seymour Duncan Phat Cat Nickel Pickup Set
- ✓ Authentic P-90 warmth and vintage character in humbucker-compatible format
- ✓ Lower output (8.0–8.5 kOhm) suits clean and moderate-gain tones
- ✓ Smooth treble with articulate midrange ideal for blues and jazz definition
- ✓ Reverse wind/reverse polarity neck eliminates hum in both-pickup mode
Why choose Seymour Duncan Invader Black Pickup Set
- ✓ High output (7.2–16.8 kOhm) and ceramic magnets excel in high-gain and metal
- ✓ Compressed attack and thick low end cut through dense mixes
- ✓ Note separation maintained even at extreme gain levels
- ✓ 4-conductor wiring enables flexible switching and trembucker compatibility
Frequently asked questions
Which is better for a beginner?
Both suit intermediate players and above. The Phat Cat works better if you're exploring vintage tones; the Invader Black suits high-gain styles. Skill level is less about the pickup and more about amp and technique.
Can I use either in a semi-hollow guitar?
The Phat Cat Nickel is specifically designed for semi-hollow and solid-body retrofits without routing, making it the natural choice. The Invader Black is standard humbucker size but better suited to solid-body guitars where high output and shielding matter most.
What is the key output difference?
The Phat Cat Neck/Bridge measures 8.0/8.5 kOhm, delivering moderate output for clean and moderate-gain tones. The Invader Black Neck/Bridge measures 7.2/16.8 kOhm with ceramic magnets and overwound coils, producing significantly higher output for high-gain applications.
Do both have microphonic feedback protection?
Yes, both use vacuum wax potting to eliminate microphonic feedback. The Phat Cat adds reverse wind/reverse polarity on the neck for hum cancellation when both pickups engage; the Invader Black relies on potting and ceramic construction for stable, controlled performance.