11402-57 vs 11993-19 — Compare
Seymour Duncan Quarter Pound P-J set Pickup vs Seymour Duncan STC-3ASB Fundamental 3-Band Tone Circuit For Active Pickups
The Quarter Pound P-J set is a passive pickup replacement for players seeking immediate tonal character and aggression without additional gear, while the STC-3ASB is an active preamp circuit for players who already have pickups and want surgical EQ control and flexibility. Choose pickups if you're upgrading your core tone; choose the preamp if you need tone-shaping tools and are okay with battery maintenance.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
Seymour Duncan STC-3ASB Fundamental 3-Band Tone Circuit For Active Pickups
Specs side by side
| Seymour Duncan Quarter Pound P-J set Pickup | Seymour Duncan STC-3ASB Fundamental 3-Band Tone Circuit For Active Pickups | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $188.00 | $195.00 |
| Brand | Seymour Duncan | Seymour Duncan |
| Pickup Type | — | Any Position |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose Seymour Duncan Quarter Pound P-J set Pickup
- ✓ Hand-built Alnico V pickups with aggressive midrange presence and defined clarity
- ✓ Passive operation — no batteries, no preamp required
- ✓ Tight low end and articulate snap designed for rock, funk, and metal
- ✓ Budget-friendly entry point to professional-grade tone
Why choose Seymour Duncan STC-3ASB Fundamental 3-Band Tone Circuit For Active Pickups
- ✓ Three-band active EQ with independent bass, midrange, and treble control
- ✓ Frequency contour switch with adjustable fine-tuning trim pots for custom shaping
- ✓ Single or dual 9V battery option for extended headroom and battery life
- ✓ Pre-wired harness and complete installation kit minimize soldering and modification
Frequently asked questions
Can I use both products together?
No. The Quarter Pound P-J set is a passive pickup replacement, while the STC-3ASB is an active preamp circuit. They serve different purposes — one changes what you plug in, the other shapes tone after the signal leaves the pickups. You would need active pickups to use the STC-3ASB effectively.
Which is better for studio recording?
The STC-3ASB offers more tone-shaping flexibility with its three-band EQ and frequency contour options, making it ideal for dialing in exact tones. The Quarter Pound P-J set delivers a fixed character based on its Alnico V design and resonant frequencies, which suits those who prefer aggressive, punchy tone straight from the source.
Do either require soldering or extensive installation?
The Quarter Pound P-J set ships ready for direct installation into standard P-J configurations with pre-soldered leads. The STC-3ASB includes a pre-wired harness that minimizes soldering, though integration into your bass control cavity does require some wiring work and battery installation.
Which is maintenance-free?
The Quarter Pound P-J set is completely passive and requires no batteries or maintenance. The STC-3ASB requires a 9V battery (or two in series), which will need periodic replacement based on usage.