11302-14-Crc vs 11303-04-B — Compare
Seymour Duncan STK-P1b P90 Soapbar Stack Cream Pickup vs Seymour Duncan SHPR-2b P-Rails Hot Bridge Black Pickup
The STK-P1b is a traditional P90 soapbar for warm, hum-free vintage tone in blues and indie music, while the SHPR-2b P-Rails offers three switchable voices (humbucker, P90, single-coil) with hot output for rock and metal players seeking tonal flexibility. Choose the STK-P1b for authentic P90 character; choose the SHPR-2b for versatility across multiple genres from one pickup.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
Seymour Duncan STK-P1b P90 Soapbar Stack Cream Pickup
Seymour Duncan SHPR-2b P-Rails Hot Bridge Black Pickup
Specs side by side
| Seymour Duncan STK-P1b P90 Soapbar Stack Cream Pickup | Seymour Duncan SHPR-2b P-Rails Hot Bridge Black Pickup | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $135.00 | $135.00 |
| Brand | Seymour Duncan | Seymour Duncan |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose Seymour Duncan STK-P1b P90 Soapbar Stack Cream Pickup
- ✓ Authentic warm P90 tone with modern hum-canceling stacked coil design
- ✓ Articulate cleans and natural mix-sitting medium output
- ✓ Compact soapbar format fits tight spaces; cream aesthetic suits vintage or contemporary builds
Why choose Seymour Duncan SHPR-2b P-Rails Hot Bridge Black Pickup
- ✓ Three distinct voices (humbucker, P90, single-coil) from one pickup for genre-switching flexibility
- ✓ Hot output with aggressive attack ideal for rock, metal, and lead work
- ✓ Drop-in humbucker cavity installation requires no routing or extensive rewiring
Frequently asked questions
Which pickup is better for metal and aggressive rock?
The SHPR-2b P-Rails Hot is designed for metal and rock with aggressive output, hot bridge calibration, and focused attack. The STK-P1b is explicitly not ideal for metal and prioritizes warm vintage tone instead.
Can I use either pickup as a drop-in replacement?
The SHPR-2b drops directly into standard humbucker or Trembucker cavities with no routing required. The STK-P1b is a soapbar format and requires a soapbar-routed cavity, making it less flexible for retrofit installations.
Which has less noise and hum?
The STK-P1b uses stacked-coil engineering to eliminate 60-cycle hum while keeping P90 character. The SHPR-2b does not specifically emphasize hum cancellation and may introduce more noise in single-coil mode depending on your guitar's grounding.
What's the main tonal difference in output?
The STK-P1b delivers medium output that sits naturally in a mix with articulate cleans and overdrive balance. The SHPR-2b features beefed-up coil wind and aggressive output calibrated for cutting attack and sustain in competitive mix environments.