11204-01-Cset vs 11204-08-Cset — Compare
Seymour Duncan APS1 Alnico II Pro Staggered Strat Cset Pickup vs Seymour Duncan APS2 Alnico II Pro Flat Strat Cset Pickup
The APS1 uses staggered magnets to even out string-to-string output, while the APS2 uses flat magnets with hum-canceling reverse-wound middle pickup and hand-ground construction. Choose the APS1 for maximum consistency across strings; choose the APS2 for authentic vintage aesthetics, quieter operation, and classic 2-4 position hum elimination.
No sales tax on orders shipped outside California — total cost beats national retailers that charge sales tax in nearly every state.
Seymour Duncan APS1 Alnico II Pro Staggered Strat Cset Pickup
Seymour Duncan APS2 Alnico II Pro Flat Strat Cset Pickup
Specs side by side
| Seymour Duncan APS1 Alnico II Pro Staggered Strat Cset Pickup | Seymour Duncan APS2 Alnico II Pro Flat Strat Cset Pickup | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $277.00 | $277.00 |
| Brand | Seymour Duncan | Seymour Duncan |
| Condition | New | New |
Why choose Seymour Duncan APS1 Alnico II Pro Staggered Strat Cset Pickup
- ✓ Staggered magnet design ensures even response across all six strings
- ✓ Simpler, more straightforward construction than APS2
- ✓ Excellent for beginners learning clean single-note articulation
- ✓ Same tonal character at a slightly lower build complexity
Why choose Seymour Duncan APS2 Alnico II Pro Flat Strat Cset Pickup
- ✓ Hand-ground magnets and hand-filed Forbon flatwork for authentic vintage construction
- ✓ Reverse-wound middle pickup eliminates hum in positions 2 and 4
- ✓ Wax potted to eliminate microphonic feedback and unwanted noise
- ✓ Better suited for professionals seeking period-correct tone and minimal noise floor
Frequently asked questions
What's the actual difference in output and tone between these two?
Both share identical DC resistance (6.4 kΩ), resonant peak (9 kHz), and EQ profile (5/4/7). The sonic difference comes from magnet geometry and construction method—the APS1's staggered design optimizes string-to-string evenness, while the APS2's flat magnets with hand-grinding deliver the classic vintage Strat character with the benefit of hum cancellation in positions 2 and 4.
Which one should I choose if I'm a beginner?
The APS1 is explicitly listed for beginners and intermediate players, while the APS2 lists intermediate as its entry level. The APS1's staggered design makes it slightly more forgiving for learning consistent tone across all strings, making it the better choice for true beginners.
Is the APS2's hum cancellation worth the extra hand-craftsmanship?
If you play in position 2 or 4 frequently and want minimal noise, yes—the reverse-wound middle pickup is valuable. If you rarely use those positions or play with gain where hum is masked, the APS1's staggered design may suit you better. The APS2's hand-ground magnets and wax potting also reduce microphonic feedback regardless of position.
Do these work in all genres listed?
Both excel in blues, rock, and country. The APS2 adds jazz to its strengths due to its quieter operation and hum elimination. Neither is designed for metal or djent—both lack the output and aggression those genres demand.